5 Gaps in Your Arizona Homeowners Policy (and How to Fix Them)

Home Insurance

5 Gaps in Your Arizona Homeowners Policy (and How to Fix Them)

Most homeowners policies leave critical holes. Here are the ones that cost people the most.

You bought homeowners insurance so you’d be protected when something goes wrong. But “protected” doesn’t always mean what you think it means. Standard HO-3 policies have real gaps – and some of the biggest losses we see are things people assumed were covered but weren’t.

Gap #1: Rebuild cost vs. market value

The price you paid for your house is not what it costs to rebuild it. Construction, materials, and labor have climbed dramatically in Arizona over the last five years. A 2,200 square foot Scottsdale home that “only” sells for $650K could easily cost $500K+ to rebuild – and if your dwelling coverage is based on an old appraisal, you could be underinsured by $100K or more.

The fix: Ask your agent for a replacement cost estimate using current AZ build costs ($200-$275/sq ft for most neighborhoods) and add Extended Replacement Cost coverage – which automatically pays 25-50% above your dwelling limit if rebuild costs blow through.

Gap #2: Water backup

Standard homeowners excludes damage from sewer/drain backups. Monsoon season and older plumbing systems make this a real Arizona risk, especially in central Phoenix neighborhoods with aging infrastructure. A basement or garage water backup event averages $5,000-$15,000 in repairs.

The fix: Add Water Backup and Sump Overflow coverage. It’s usually $25-$75 per year.

Gap #3: Jewelry and high-value items

Most policies cap jewelry theft at $1,500 and art, collectibles, firearms, and electronics at similarly low limits. If you lost an engagement ring, a watch collection, or family heirlooms in a burglary – the standard policy isn’t enough.

The fix: Schedule your valuables. Scheduled items carry no deductible, cover mysterious disappearance (you just lose them), and are rated by appraisal value. A $10,000 engagement ring usually costs about $75-$125/year to schedule.

Gap #4: Ordinance and law

When your home gets damaged, it has to be rebuilt to current code – even if the damaged parts weren’t up to code. Code upgrades (new electrical, energy efficiency, seismic, accessibility) can add 10-25% to rebuild costs. A standard policy may only cover a tiny fraction of that.

The fix: Add or increase Ordinance & Law coverage to at least 25% of your dwelling limit. It’s often a few dollars a month.

Gap #5: Liability for pools, trampolines, and dogs

Arizona is pool country. Pools (and trampolines, and certain dog breeds) are “attractive nuisances” in legal-speak – meaning if someone gets hurt, you’re liable even if they shouldn’t have been there. Standard liability limits of $100,000-$300,000 can be blown through fast in a serious injury case.

The fix: Buy an umbrella policy. A $1M umbrella usually costs $200-$400/year and sits on top of your home and auto liability limits. For families with pools, teen drivers, or meaningful assets – it’s the best insurance dollar you can spend.

The bottom line

These five fixes typically cost an extra $150-$400 per year – and they can save you $100,000+ when something actually goes wrong. Most carriers let you add them mid-term, no re-shopping required.

Free Home Policy Review

Let us find the gaps – no cost, no pressure

Send us your current declarations page and we’ll highlight where you’re over-covered, under-covered, or exposed.

Request My Review

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *