lig_florida landlord insurance | Lux Insurance Group

Florida Landlord Insurance | Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville | Lux Insurance Group

Florida Landlord Insurance

Florida’s insurance market in 2026 is the most challenging in the country. After Hurricane Ian and the broader carrier withdrawal of 2022-2024, Florida lost over 30 admitted carriers. The state’s last-resort insurer (Citizens Property Insurance) is the largest underwriter in the state. Premiums are 2-3x what they were five years ago. Coverage gaps are common. Navigating this market for a rental property requires a broker who knows which carriers are still writing your zip code, your roof age, your construction type, and your specific risk profile.

If you’d rather just talk to a licensed agent, call 480.999.2308 or request a free quote.

What’s specific about insuring a Florida rental in 2026

1. Windstorm coverage is the dominant cost driver. Coastal counties (Orange, Hillsborough, Pinellas, Volusia, Brevard, Lee, Collier) have separate windstorm deductibles, often 2-5% of dwelling value. For a $500K property, that’s a $10K-$25K wind deductible BEFORE you see any insurance payout.

2. Flood insurance is sold separately (NFIP or private market). Most landlord policies do NOT include flood. If your property is in flood zone A, V, AE, or VE – flood insurance is mandatory for any mortgaged property AND highly recommended for cash-owned. Average annual flood premium in FL is $700-$2,500.

3. Roof age is the single biggest underwriting trigger. Many carriers won’t write roofs older than 15 years. Some require 4-point inspections (electrical, HVAC, plumbing, roof) for properties 20+ years old.

4. Short-term rental in Florida is a legal patchwork. State law mostly permits STR but local governments (Miami Beach, Orlando, Naples, Key West) have strict registration and zoning requirements. STR insurance is a separate, more expensive product.

5. Hurricane preparedness affects underwriting. Properties without roof straps, hurricane shutters, impact windows, or in newer construction (post-2002 building code) get materially better rates.

Typical FL landlord premium ranges (2026)

  • $300K-$500K dwelling, recent roof: $1,800-$3,500
  • $500K-$800K dwelling (Tampa, Orlando typical): $2,800-$5,500
  • $800K-$1.5M dwelling (luxury Tampa, Orlando, Lake Nona): $4,500-$9,000
  • Coastal county property with windstorm: +30-60% premium
  • Add separate flood insurance (zone A/V): +$700-$2,500/year

Carriers we actively place in Florida

Independent broker – we shop across:

Citizens Property Insurance (state insurer of last resort), Heritage, Florida Peninsula, Frontline, Federated National, Universal, Tower Hill, Slide Insurance, plus specialty markets for high-value or unusual profiles.

Geographic priority service

We write rental insurance across all of Florida, with concentrated expertise in:

Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville, Miami, Fort Myers

Coordination with property management

If your property is professionally managed by Lux Management Group or another firm, we coordinate the insurance to align with the management contract.

Ready to talk?

Call 480.999.2308 or request a free quote. Most quotes turn around in 24-48 hours.

Also see:

Lux Insurance Group – independent insurance broker, licensed in AZ, FL, AL.

Related insurance pages